For much of this fast-paced match, Bournemouth supporters were anticipating the possibility of reaching the summit of the Premier League, albeit potentially only for a few hours, and handing only Crystal Palace's second-ever home loss of 2025.
Andoni Iraola's impressive side had led through two goals from youngster Eli Junior Kroupi before being caught up by Jean-Philippe Mateta and thought they had won it when replacement Ryan Christie found the net with two minutes of normal time left.
But Mateta, who netted on his first appearance for France in midweek, had different plans as he scored a late penalty to complete his hat-trick, although he could potentially won it had he converted a great chance at the end.
Coaching Focus Before the Match
A great deal of the focus before this game had centered on the individuals in the technical areas, with both Iraola and Oliver Glasner without deals in the summer and sought after by clubs with larger budgets.
Palace also are positioned in the upper section of the table having failed to win any of their first eight games the previous campaign but demonstrated once again the team spirit they have fostered under their Austrian manager.
Early Bournemouth Lead
Glasner has established his results at Palace on a solid defence yet they ended up behind after just seven minutes after an impressive start from the visitors.
The speed with which Bournemouth's attackers pressed from the first whistle unsettled their opponents and it was from an initial corner that Kroupi, starting only his second league game since arriving from Bournemouth's sister club Lorient in the summer due to a calf injury to Evanilson, was able to score the excellent Antoine Semenyo's flick on despite a hint of offside.
Mateta ought to have leveled the score from Yeremy Pino's cross in the middle of the opening period as Palace started to find some gaps in Bournemouth's revamped defence.
Second Goal and Controversy
An impeccable piece of control in his own half was the catalyst for Bournemouth's next goal, with Chris Richards left for dead as he raced down the wing and sent in a low cross.
Marc Guéhi, who Glasner confirmed this week will leave on a no-fee move next season, could only divert it straight to Kroupi and Henderson was unable to prevent his shot from crossing the line.
Palace started the second period with much more purpose but a incident of controversy five minutes in hinted that it might not be their day.
Ismaila Sarr was through on goal when he was fouled by Marcos Senesi, although referee Jarred Gillett ruled that only deserved a caution as he believed the Senegal forward was heading away from goal.
Dramatic Recovery and Final Equalizer
After much deliberation from the VAR, and to Glasner's obvious frustration, the initial call remained.
But Palace's luck suddenly changed when Mateta's goal from Daniel Muñoz's cross was initially disallowed for offside before being quickly reversed.
Shortly after he had his second goal of the afternoon when he somehow turned the ball in from a tight angle after Petrovic had saved from Muñoz as Selhurst Park exploded.
Senesi escaped again when he seemed to push Sarr over when he was advancing on goal but Gillett dismissed Palace's protests.
Eddie Nketiah had the ball in the net but this time it was rightly disallowed for offside, with Christie thinking he had stolen the victory after ramming home from close range.
But Mateta ensured that points ended level when Bafodé Diakité was judged to have committed a foul on Guéhi in added time.